WCIRB Approves Dual Wage Threshold Increases for 2026: What California Contractors Need to Know

Author, Jeremy Hoolihan, Partner, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

The Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) has reviewed and approved a proposal to increase the hourly wage threshold for 13 out of the 16 dual wage classifications by $2 to $5 per hour that would go into effect September 1, 2026, once Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara agrees. 

This upcoming change could have a direct impact on your workers’ compensation premium, if you employ workers in any trade subject to the dual wage classifications.

There are 16 dual wage classifications that will affect California Contractors:  

Dual Wage Classifications	Curent Threshold Effective 2024	Recommended Threshold Change	Recommended Threshold
5027/5028 Masonry	$35	+$2	$37
5190/5140 Electrical	$36	+$4	$40
5183/5187 Plumbing/HVAC	$32	+$3	$35
5185/5186 Automatic Sprinkler Install	$33	+$3	$36
5201/5205 Concrete or Cement Work	$33	+$3	$36
5403/5432 Carpentry	$41	+$5	$46
5446/5447 Wallboard Install	$41	+$4	$45
5467/5470 Glaziers	$39	+$4	$43
5474/5482 Painting/Waterproofing	$32	+$4	$36
5484/5485 Plastering or Stucco Work	$38	+$4	$42
5538/5542 Sheet Metal	$33	+$4	$37
5552/5553 Roofing	$31	+$2	$33
5632/5633 Steel Framing	$41	+$5	$46
6218/6220 Excavation/Grading	$40	TBD	TBD
6307/6308 Sewer Construction	$40	TBD	TBD
6315/6316 Water/Gas Mains	$40	TBD	TBD

Data from the WCIRB’s Classification and Rating Committee Meeting on November 11, 2025.
https://www.wcirb.com/sites/default/files/2025-11/20251111_cr_presentation.pdf

In California, certain construction class codes use a dual wage system to separate employees into two tiers:

• Higher Wage – Workers earning at or above a set hourly threshold qualify for lower workers’ compensation rates because statistically these workers have lower claim frequency and severity.

• Lower Wage – Workers earning below the threshold qualify for in the higher workers’ compensation rates because they tend to be less experienced and have a higher frequency and severity of claims.

The WCIRB periodically adjusts these thresholds to reflect rising wages, inflation, and updated claims data. When wages increase across the industry but thresholds stay static, more employees drift into the higher wage threshold which creates an imbalance. Therefore, the WCIRB now reviews and adjusts the thresholds every two years.

In preparation for proposed wage threshold changes, business owners may want to consider implementing the following strategies:

1. Review your payroll and identify employees earning near the current dual wage threshold.

2. Model the impact and estimate how a $2 to $5 per hour increase could affect your premium classification mix.

3. Evaluate wage adjustments by comparing the cost of modest raises against the savings from qualifying for lower workers’ compensation rates.

4. Keep accurate records! Maintain clean timecards and payroll documentation for upcoming audits.

5. Talk with your broker now to help you analyze potential exposure and prepare for your 2026 renewal.

The WCIRB’s Classification and Rating Committee reviewed these proposed increases in a meeting on November 11, 2025 and has approved them as part of the Bureau’s regulatory filing next spring for Lara’s consideration. If accepted, the updated thresholds would apply to policies incepting on or after September 1, 2026.

For any questions relating to how the dual wage threshold increase will affect your workers’ compensation premiums, reach out to me at (619) 937-0174 or jhoolihan@ranchomesa.com.

Workers' Comp Rate Increases On the Way with Margaret Hartmann: Part 3

In the final episode of a three-part series, President David Garcia and Margaret Hartmann, Sr. VP and Chief Marketing Officer with BHHC, discuss the WCIRB's proposed 11.2% workers’ compensation rate increase in California. They explore how this may impact employers, and actionable steps businesses can take to mitigate rising premiums.

Dave Garcia: Hi, you're listening to Rancho Mesa's StudioOne™ podcast where each week we break down complex insurance and safety topics to help your businesses thrive. I'm your host, Dave Garcia. Thanks for joining us.

So today with the WCIRB's recent announcement of 11.2% recommended rate increase in workers' compensation, it definitely feels to me like the workers' compensation marketplace in California is about to change, and with that in mind, we've invited Margaret Hartman, the Senior

Vice President/Chief Marketing Officer at Berkshire Hathaway Home State Companies, who's one of the largest specialty workers' compensation carriers in California, to give us some insights as to how this recommendation came about, what are the areas that are driving this increase, and what employers can do to try and mitigate the rate increases.

Hi Margaret, welcome back to StudioOne. Thanks for joining me today.

Margaret Hartman: Thanks for having me.

DG: It seems to me Margaret, given all the data and recent recommendations that many employers have not all are going to experience rate increases on the renewals. You know, we know Commissioner Lara--generally speaking--the Bureau makes their recommendation which they have at 11.2. Commissioner Lara--usually in June so it could be any day now-- will make his recommendation.

MH: I think it's today. There's a hearing today. He may not decide today, but I know there's a hearing today.

DG: Okay, well it could be today and today, so the we're taping this it's June the 10th. You know, I don't have a crystal ball. My crystal ball has snow in it I think he's going to come in with a recommendation of somewhere between four and six percent increase or somewhere in that range, six to seven, I don't know. Regardless, it's going to be a recommended increase, which we have not seen in over a decade in workers' compensation. So while that means it's going to put upward pressure on rate, that doesn't mean every single policyholder in California will see the same rate increase as another.

So your experience modifications come into play, your claims experience is going to come into play, and most importantly too, your safety practices. And this is where we're really auditing that and then allowing your broker to present that to the marketplace and what you're doing to prevent injuries from occurring and then what you do once an injury occurs. I think that is the really, really critical right now and Margaret, what actions would you recommend they try to do, if they see an increase to try to mitigate the increase and in some cases maybe there's still a decrease out there?

MH: Sure. And I mean, we've talked a lot about some specific ways that employers can help themselves out. But really, that experience modification that you're talking about is the best way to manage your insurance premium. So as you mentioned, there's going to be probably some sort of rate increase and probably single-digit, I'd imagine. And I agree with you four to six, three to five, something like that, but you're experiencing it. So that's, the carrier will have a base rate increase, increase likely, but your net rate is not going to be the same as that base rate. And the only way to impact that is to have a low mod. So try to manage your experience mod as much as you can.

And again, that's all the things we talked about, having the safest work environment that you can so you can prevent accidents from happening and then partnering with a carrier that's focused on providing the best possible care, getting claims resolved quickly and efficiently.

DG: Yeah, and we know, as Margaret said, it’s your premiums can be predicated on your payrolls by class code, multiplied by the final rate from the carrier, multiplied by your experience modification. But to get to the final rate of the carrier, there is some subjectivity still available with the carriers. So they can deviate a certain percentage, usually it's plus or minus 50%, off of their base rate. But in order to warrant those credits, it's going to take real items to try to get the carrier to understand why they should apply those credits. So when we talk about that out there, what your broker does is he or she submits to a carrier your information. We call that a submission.

So Margaret, how important is receiving a complete submission early in the process of benefit to the policyholder in getting the best possible rates?

MH: Yeah, I think it's incredibly important. So an underwriter is going to be getting a lot of these

applications, right, they're coming to their desk. And the ones that are complete, where they don't have to call or send an email or ask questions or try to get more information, those are going to rise to the top of the stack and they'll be able to process them quickly and maybe get the quotation out, right?

And then that starts the process of negotiation or tweaking that price. So the earlier that you can do that, the better. I think it definitely helps. And then the more complete the information is, you know, that will help the underwriter better price the risk as well.

DG: Yeah, are there any parts of submission that, you know, they're all important, but does any part of it carry more weight for your underwriting team than another area?

MH: Yeah, I mean, I think we look at the account as a whole, but obviously, loss history. It goes a lot into how we view an account, how we price an account. You know, a lot of times there's a supplemental application and employers out there have checked the box. "Oh, yeah, I have a safety program," blah, blah, blah.

But sometimes it becomes a check the box versus a, you know, "What exactly are you really doing?" But the proofs and the pudding, what does the loss history look like?

We also pay a lot of attention to payroll too. Is the account growing and if there's substantial growth in the payroll versus the expiring year, what's going on is there going to be growth and if there's going to be growth, it's not to say we would dislike the account, but that's one where we may want to keep an eye on them. how are they going to manage hiring practices to bring on all these new people? What kind of projects are they going to be taking on? It just goes into us understanding what that risk is isn't understanding how to price it.

Likewise, if the payroll's dropping substantially, why is that happening? Is there a layoff spending, those kinds of things? And then we look at the risk quality, risk management, safety program. Those are harder to get our arms around because as I said, a lot of people will just kind of check the box. Yeah, we have these things. So a narrative is really important from the broker, kind of putting together the story of the account.

The loss history, none of these things are the only, they're only a little piece of the puzzle, right? So maybe the loss history is such that it looks really bad and then in the last two years, it's improved. If you can substantiate why it's improved, not just send, here's the loss runs and here's the application, but this employer really took some steps to improve their loss profile. You know, they hired a new risk manager, they automated a lot of their procedures. Those are things that are going to play into the price and you're going to go, well, I think that account is going to perform the way it has the last two years, not what happened in the past. And they may still have a really high mod because of past poor losses. So it can help kind of paint the picture of what's going on with the account today.

DG: I think that's great you know what it sounds to me and it's high time it's time for everybody go to work, you know the broker needs to go to work and not just check boxes needs to provide more information. I know we regularly dig deep into those things if payrolls are going up maybe it's just payroll inflation maybe there's no new employees everybody just got pay raises or now they're doing union work versus not. Like you need to know more than just the basic facts. And I love the summaries, you know, we're a big proponent of that. But I think I'm always three dimensional, always seems to be the best. And so I know we've worked in the past Margaret, when we get looking at a new potential client of ours, we put all the all the paperwork together, the summaries, the losses, the payrolls, all those things, but it's still paper.

And what I think I like, you know, how we work with you is we'll say, "Hey, can we go out and do a joint call together so you can actually ask the questions and see the operations?"

Do you think having the carrier go out prior to quoting the business is a benefit to the business?

MH: Yeah, absolutely it is. And we love to go out and see the prospects. There's nothing like meeting somebody face-to-face, looking them in the eye and seeing the operation as well. And on the other hand too, they have an opportunity to meet us and see their service team and what they’re going to get from us. You know, policy, especially in the workers’ comp, you know, they all kind of cover the same thing, there’s not really a lot changes besides maybe a deductible. So it's really the service that's important. And so I think it's good for an employer to actually meet their service team and see who's going to be working with them in the future. Yeah, I mean, absolutely. We love to do that. We're always open to having our folks go out and meet with prospects face to face.

And now with virtual too, a lot of times we will do them virtually. It's easier and you can do them quickly. You can get them set up quickly.

DG: I'm sure you can do more than two or three in a day if you need to.

MH: Right, so either way. We're happy to have those meetings. And it does make an impact.

DG: So employers, I would encourage you, you're working with your broker currently to engage with them early. And when we say early, you're probably talking 120 days outside of your renewal date. So you want to get this process started early, particularly with the changes that are occurring. And then as a team, you guys decide should we involve some carrier interviews where we get an opportunity to talk to the carriers, and you can talk to more than one. You know, if you just want to get a comparison like who did you like better? They both offer great services and things like that. So it is going to, it's time to roll up our sleeves and you know really get to work here. There's some tremendously great work comp carriers--Berkshire Hathaway heading the

List--that are out there. So I would just encourage you to you know to go out and work with your broker partner and make sure that they're doing the job that they're supposed to be doing too.

So Margaret you know I appreciate your time today before we wrap up is there anything else you'd like to share with our audience.

MH: Gosh, no, I mean, I think we've covered a lot today. And again, I think our mission is really to provide, you know, the best possible care for injured workers, because at the end of the day, you know, that's what's going to result in the best claims costs more effective for employers. And it's the right thing to do. And keeping employees safe is the right thing to do, not just for, you know, an employer's business, but just because, you know, we care about people.

DG: Yep. And you've demonstrated that, you know, time and time again. So I think everybody out there, you know, there's been a lot of things that we've discussed today. If you're looking for more information, you know, reach out to myself or to Margaret directly, you know, you can go to our site, RanchoMesa.com.

And we're happy to help, you don't have to be our client, we're in this together. So Margaret, listen, I can't thank you enough for joining me today in StudioOne and kind of sharing your insights to this changing worker compensation marketplace. Last, anything else? How's Notre Dame football going to be this year? What do you think? What's your prediction?

MH: Oh boy, I don't know. Don't throw that curve at me. I have no idea, but I'm still looking forward to the season.

DG: Okay, there you go. All right. Well, listen, thank you all for joining me today in StudioOne. If you found this information useful, you can subscribe to our podcast channel, which is StudioOne, all one word, and it can be found on literally all the podcast applications. So thank you again for your time. Goodbye for now.

Workers' Comp Rate Increases On the Way with Margaret Hartmann: Part 2

In the second episode of a three-part series, President David Garcia continues his discussion with Margaret Hartmann, Sr. VP and Chief Marketing Officer with BHHC, and explains how companies can mitigate cumulative trauma claims in light of the WCIRB’s recent 11.2% recommended rate increase.

David Garcia: Hi, you're listening to Rancho Mesa's Studio One podcast, where each week we break down complex insurance and safety topics to help your businesses thrive. I'm your host, Dave Garcia, thanks for joining us.

So today, with the WCARB's recent announcement of a 11.2% recommended rate increase in workers' compensation, it definitely feels to me like the workers' compensation marketplace in California is about to change and with that in mind, we've invited Margaret Hartman, the Senior Vice President, Chief Marketing Officer at Berkshire, Hathaway Homestate Companies, which's one of the largest specialty workers' compensation carriers in California, to give us some insights as to how this recommendation came about, what are the areas that are driving this increase and what employers can do to try and mitigate the rate increases.

Hi Margaret, welcome back to Studio One. Thanks for joining me today.

Margaret Hartman: Thanks for having me.

DG: I know that Berkshire Hathaway, we've worked with you guys for any number of years. We have a tremendously strong relationship so I'm very familiar with a lot of the services that you're able to provide policy holders, but are you guys looking at taking any targeted steps to help manage this growing impact of CT claims as a company?

MH: Yeah, I'm glad you asked. We are taking this very seriously and we have taken some proactive steps here, including you know we have a task force a little committee that we’ve set up internally within our claims teams to try and manage some of these claims and have strategies for, you know, we want to make sure that we make decisions on these quickly, ones that are legitimate that we’re getting people treated quickly and though the system so that we can get them back to health and back to work as quickly as possible.

DG: You know, that's a really, really smart idea. I know you guys did the same thing during COVID, when you started to see COVID claims, you kind of bunched those into a unit because the repetitiveness of the type of claim led to expertise in managing the claim.

MH: Right.

DG: Yeah. That's a, that's, that's awesome. I'm glad to hear you're doing that.

MH: Yeah, so we've, you know, we've improved our tracking, like our CT tracking approach implemented some analytics on that so we can dig deeper on some of the doctors that we're seeing, some of the players in the CT space. We ramped up our training around the compensability decisions involved, more managers in the process. We've just, we've made a lot of targeted changes, including using data analytics again and identifying the players in that CT space. And then we really kind of launched a collaborative approach on how we're managing these claims. So along with our claims professionals and consolidating cases with specific claims professionals, we also have specialty teams that are pretty unique, including our medical excellence team, which is headed by our medical director, Dr. Lynn, who's an occupational health specialist. So she's developed some strategies for helping us deal with these. We have a roundtable approach that we've now implemented for some of these CT claims.

We also have a contribution team which is kind of unique as well. So, as I mentioned, a lot of these, since they happen over a span of time, it often, you know, somebody may work for multiple employers and we want to make sure that our policyholders are only paying for their fair share of those claims. So we have a contribution teams that helps us manage those third party recoveries and get those dollars back if somebody else is responsible for a portion of those claims. We also have in-house council and a very robust special investigation unit, for when we do start to see some of those like mass layoff type filings of CT claims, we'll get our special investigations unit involved in those as well.

DG: Is that unit also involved with I guess the slang word would be capping you know by attorneys?

MH: Yes.

DG: Can you explain what capping is and maybe how that hurts the system if you're the employer or the insurance carrier?

MH: Right well there's been several really, really high profile cases of capping here in California where people are actually going out and trying to that people to come in and get medical treatment, signing them up, say you have a claim and we'll send you in to see these doctors. I mean, to the point where some of them are really egregious, like people were having surgeries that they didn't need just so that they could get paid and then they're getting paid for that. So our special investigation unit is very involved in those types of cases. Those are, of course, very, very extreme cases, but we want to make sure that they're involved. And so when we start spotting some of these trends and behaviors and things, we will definitely bring them into the loop. And they work with the local district attorney's offices. A lot of them have very good relationships with the DA's offices so that we can move some of these cases forward and make sure that there's no abuse there. And then, you know, all of that is kind of what we're doing after the fact. But probably the most important thing, and I'm going to talk about this again when we talk about what employers can do, is getting loss control involved early on. I think our loss control specialists are very well versed in trying to identify these possible CT exposures that may occur in the workplace. And we may not be able to eliminate them all, but we can reduce the risk often.

DG: Well that's great. So let's switch gears now and start talking about what would you recommend employers do to try to mitigate this risk.

MH: Well prevention starts at the workplace level of course so one of the most effective things employers can do is foster early reporting, open communication, many CT claims stem from issues that were never reported or addressed early If somebody is having problems with their wrists, for example, because they're doing, you know, repetitive typing, we can get an ergonomic eval and get somebody out there to help prevent that injury from progressing because now we're going to have the right equipment in place for them to be able to do the job safer. And often some of these modifications are not expensive to do.

DG: And that ergonomic evaluation is something that your loss control department can assist with?

MH: They can assist with it. We also have a kind of a do -it -yourself app. Okay. You know, there's a lot of them out there. I mean, the nice thing for employers right now is that there are so many safety resources before you had to go through some library and now you can kind of Google YouTube videos and get them from anywhere.

DG: Right.

MH: So I'd say, you know, stay informed, stay engaged in what kind of preventative measures are out there. And then just stay tuned into what's going on with your workforce as well. Strong return to work programs also can help with that as well. I want to highlight another thing that, you know, we have nurse triage that's available for employers. So nurse triage programs where the injury gets reported to a nurse and they help to triage that injury, get them to the right medical provider network doctor and get people in appropriate treatment right away. That can also really help with early reporting.

Also, that these nurses take a pretty detailed medical history. So that can really go a long way to in helping like set the groundwork for the defense of a claim. If say the specific injury you talked about, sometimes a specific injury, then turns into a CT, then turns into multiple body parts, we'll have a detailed and recorded statement from the nurse with a medical history of the injured worker. So a lot of times we can use that to help defend against that spread. Now, you know, it was a risk, but now it's an elbow and a shoulder and a neck.

DG: Yeah, you know, big, big proponent of nurse triage. I just think it's you guys implemented that now I don't know several years ago and in just with our clients that utilize it we've seen a significant decrease in claims kind of growing arms and legs because it's make that phone call at the initial time the injury occurs. This is of course assuming a non -life -threatening type of injury. It's recorded as you said it's a very thorough, you know, evaluation by a nurse on the other end, but it is recorded. And then the nurses then report the claim into your claims department. So there's really hardly any lag time in reporting the claim. And then it gives your claims people an opportunity to get it from the jump. I just think that's a, if you're an employer out there and you're not asking your current carriers, if they have this availability you may consider moving to a carrier, like a Berkshire Hathaway, that does provide this service because it comes to you at no cost. Berkshire absorbs this cost and it's just a way of you know treating your employees better. They feel like you really care because you're getting immediate assistance right away. You know it also eliminates the drive time between wherever the injury occurred and whatever facility you're taking them to be seen. If it's not an urgent situation then they're just sitting in an urgent care waiting room and it's not very productive. So you know we've seen that the claim handled better and we've seen productivity have less of an impact negatively for our clients that use it. So I think nurse triage is really something that everybody should be using regularly.

MH: Yeah, I Agreed.

DG: What other things Margaret?

MH: Again, I'm going to highlight loss control, you know, loss control specialists can help develop a plan to address some of the CT exposures that that may occur in the workplace. Some wellness programs and I know you guys implemented that mobility stretch program for landscapers. That is also very helpful if somebody's already, you know, stretched and they're loose and it can help prevent injuries. And if they're doing that consistently, it can also help prevent a CT claim.

DG: Yeah, yeah, thanks for bringing that up. We did, you know, we worked closely with your team to identify, you know, what is the predominant type of injury a landscaper might have. We found it to be lower back. It looked for the root cause of what it's what were they doing in those situations. Then identified a stretching program that helped mitigate that when they were going to be doing whatever that procedure in the work day entailed. And you know, I think when we do that, whether it's a broker, the carrier, the combination of the broker and the carrier, and then the employer, the worker feels like they matter, that somebody actually cares about them.

And you know, most people, that's all they're really looking for. It's like I want to provide a living for my family. I want to go to a work environment that I feel safe, that I feel valued. And so we're going to switch just a little bit about culture too. Do you find culture, you know, being a part of this that an employer can, you know, I mean, there's so many things, aging workforce.

So let's hold off on culture. Talk to me about aging workforce. I'm in that category. I'm 67 years

old. I was hoping to skip it, but we really need to talk about it. So is there any plan, you know, that you think an employer can do for handling the aging workforce like me?

MH: Well, again, I just think it has to be acknowledged and addressed. So, you know, Bureau of Labor Statistics is saying employees age 65 or older has grown 117 % in the last 20 years. So people are just staying in the workforce-

MH: -A lot longer. And, you know, I think employers just need to be cognizant of that and that there may be work modifications that can and should be done to accommodate some of these workers just to keep them also protected.

DG: Yeah.

MH: Often we will see CT claims and it's kind of the retirement claim after a prolonged, you know, like 10 year of doing heavy lifting, right? If it is some of these workers, you know, they're great employees. And that's why people keep them on and they want to continue to contribute. And I think that there are some ways that you can strategize on keeping them safe. So and I, I'm going to highlight loss control and reaching out to them or some of some guidance on some of those plans. And then, if there is going to be a pending layoff, there's some things that can be done in advance to prepare as well. So again, I think the partnership between employer and carrier, just open communication and knowing what's going on early on, we can help. We can't eliminate all of the exposure, but we can help mitigate some of it.

DG: Yeah, we get asked this question a lot prior to a layoff or even just during the regular work week is it helpful to have anybody acknowledge sign something saying I don't presently have an injury you know so they're going to be laid off and then you say great are you know you're okay yes would you mind acknowledging that is that just a pipe dream or is that something that maybe an employer should think about doing does it help at all if they have that document?

MH: I think it certainly can help and I think that there's you know the other side will argue well then are you putting it in their mind that you know now they've had a claim. I think there's ways to ask those questions that are you know are still legitimate we don't want to certainly be you know sneaky in the way we're asking it but we do want We do want to ask, is there anything we could do to make the workplace safer? How do you feel about the things that we have in place to keep you safe? Maybe having some of those questions. There are some ways that I think it does help if you can set that groundwork early on. Again, you might not be able to completely defend any of these cases, but it can just be one more thing. Look, we do ask how people feel at the end of their shifts, how people feel about our ability to keep them safe, and there was no issues at all until six months post layoff, and now all of a sudden we're getting this litigation. But all along they were saying that everything was okay. So I think it can help, and again, it's about really developing the right strategy and talking to our loss control professionals about how to go about doing that. That kind of tees up culture in a way, you know, the empathy, the care, all of those types of things. So, do you think that the culture of an organization can really impact the number of CT claims a business might have?

MH: I think it's probably the best way to impact the number of CT claims. You know, some of the things you were saying earlier about employees feeling heard and valued and safe, you know, physically and emotionally, you know, culture plays this huge role because those employees are likely to report issues early. And they're also not likely to litigate because they feel angry or disenfranchised or because they've been treated unfairly. So I think it's probably the most impactful thing that you can do is to have that really good culture. And on the other hand, we see environments where morale is very low and the culture's not good. And employees will find a way to retaliate on that. So it's often we'll see like a group of CT claims and they'll all be in one department or one unit or one team or reporting to one supervisor.

So those issues about leadership in your organization, you know, have to be addressed. And so yes, I think culture isn't just like a nice to have, it's actually a risk management tool.

DG: Yeah, and it's, you know, it's not to the point where you have to say, you know, the inmates are running the asylum kind of thing, it's like, no, but you know, it's the golden rule, right? Treat others that you'd like to be treated. So I think if you're, you know, seeing things or observing things that you don't feel are right, you need to do something to correct it. And I think that feedback to ask those questions like, is there anything else we could do or can be doing to make your job better, safer, more productive, things like that. It's an overused term, culture, you know, like what does that really mean? But boy, I'll tell you, I'm sure you've seen this, when you walk into certain businesses, within five minutes, you can see that on the good or bad culture scale, you're like, this is an energy company, these people are engaged, these people are happy to be here, they're working well, and you can walk into a company like, I don't think anybody wants to be here. It seems very punitive or something.

So I think it's a really good measure for us. And maybe another transition point here is to say, hey, do you think it's now time, given the changes that we see coming in the marketplace, that employers should really fully audit their safety plans, their cultures, and be looking for areas to improve it? Do you think that would be step one for a lot of companies out there right now?

MH: 100%. I mean, it's a best practice anyway to be constantly looking and evaluating and enhancing your safety program. But now with what we're seeing in the market and appending rate increase, it's really actually critical. And I think what you said about, you know, culture to wrap that up, you know, you can tell and a company has a really good safety culture. And if you want to help improve it, again, I'm going to make a pitch for loss control and our loss control especially, they do a lot of training on safety culture, train the trainers, training managers and lead people to do that. Because those are the key people within the organization. You know, you might say it at the top, but if it's not happening at the management level, it's probably not happening, and they have a lot of ideas. One of the strategies, as an example, that was mentioned to me was we had an employer that they had one of their lead people that was a very long-term employee that was bilingual. They have Spanish-speaking workforce, and he volunteered as part of his leadership responsibilities to be accountable for the work comp claims. If there was a work comp claim, he was kind of the go-to that they could come and ask questions on what to do, who to go to, how to report. And having that be somebody that was actually out there that was a worker on the floor made a huge impact with that company where they were having a problem with late reporting. So, that's just one little example of what an employer might do.

DG: Yeah, and there's, you know, a company safety program, it's like an octopus. It has a lot of different arms to it. You could be looking for root causes of injuries, what safety trainings are you providing to attend any workshops. If you have a claim or you engage, as you mentioned earlier, with a return to work program, are you reporting the claims timely? How are you investigating the claims you're looking for, hey an injury occurred, we should do an accident investigation and then use that as a training with other employees So that we don't have that reoccurrence of that issue because we've now trained for it benchmarking themselves against industry peers. How am I doing against other landscapers or whoever it happens to be I probably any one of those things you can spend a lot of time on but you need to tackle them You know those are all things and there's the list can kind of go on and on. Are there any one in particular that stands out to you? Or is that just-

MH: Well, you know, I'd say all of the above I mean I think everything you mentioned is really important and helping to manage claims costs and have a good safety culture and you know as I said before safety resources are readily available everywhere yeah and even if you don't you If you're a small employer and you say, "Well, I don't have a loss control consultant that's coming out," I mean, almost all carriers have safety centers, websites, and all sorts of tools and resources that can help keep employees safe.

And we haven't talked yet about return to work programs. And with indemnity payments on the rise, and I recently saw a study by another large multi-line carrier, but they write a lot of work with composition here in California, and they were noticing that disability days are very much on the rise. So it's important to get employees back to work as quickly as possible. And some employers don't have the ability to modify jobs, so there's no modified work available.

We have a transitional work program so we can get people back to work at local nonprofits. It gets employees back to some kind of modified duty, feeling like they're doing something to add value and help get them back on the path to recovery. So I would encourage a return to work program for all employers, especially given that we're seeing those increases and wages are continuing to go up too. So temporary disabilities tied to state average weekly wage, so we've seen some pretty big increases the past couple of years.

DG: Yeah, and you know, we've been big proponents of that and utilized your resources, whether it's, as you mentioned, kind of the re-employability side of your business where you do put them out into nonprofits or your other program, Shakley, which actually sends the work to their house.

MH: Right.

DG: So they don't even have to leave their house if that was the need. And we've just seen tremendous improvement in returning them back to their customary job.

And it also, just for employers out there, if you’re able to continue any of the wage during that period of time, any portion of it, it comes off of that temporary disability benefit so, your wages that you’re going to pay that person this work does not accumulate to go towards your experience modification. So, only the actual temporary disability payment that the carrier is making on behalf of you go into that calculation. So, you know, for our clients, they're very aware of that, they understand, you know, how many dollars of claim value is equal to one point of claim, and they realize, well, if I just pay this person X, I've reduced my experience modification by one, three, five points. So, there's just a lot of benefit to doing it. So I would definitely encourage you to take a look at that. Make sure that your place in your business with a carrier like Berkshire Hathaway that offers those tools.

Margaret, listen, I can't thank you enough for joining me today in StudioOne and kind of sharing your insights to this changing worker compensation marketplace. And thank you all for joining me today in StudioOne. If you found this information useful, you can subscribe to our podcast channel, which is StudioOne, all one word, and it can be found on literally all the podcast applications. So thank you again for your time. Goodbye for now.

Workers' Comp Rate Increases On the Way with Margaret Hartmann: Part 1

In the first episode of a three-part series, President David Garcia sits down with Margaret Hartmann, Sr. VP and Chief Marketing Officer with BHHC, to explain the outcome of WCIRB’s recent 11.2% recommended rate increase, and offer insight on what areas are driving this increase.

David Garcia: Hi, you're listening to Rancho Mesa's StudioOne™ podcast, where each week we break down complex insurance and safety topics to help your businesses thrive. I'm your host, Dave Garcia. Thanks for joining us.

So today, with the WCIRB's recent announcement of 11.2 % recommended rate increase in workers' compensation, it definitely feels to me like the workers' compensation marketplace in California is about to change. And with that in mind, we've invited Margaret Hartman, the Senior Vice President, Chief Marketing Officer, Berkshire Hathaway Home State Companies, who's one of the largest specialty workers' compensation carriers in California, to give us some insights as to how this recommendation came about, what are the areas that are driving this increase, and what employers can do to try and mitigate the rate increases. Hi, Margaret. Welcome back to Studio One. Thanks for joining me today.

Margaret Hartman: Thanks for having me.

DG: All right. Well, let's just roll up our sleeves and jump into this thing. So starting with the 11.2 rate increase being the recommendation by the Bureau, and the root causes driving it, aside from cumulative trauma claims, which we definitely will talk about today, what are the other areas that are driving this recommended increase?

MH: Okay, well, I think first we have to start with medical cost inflation, which we thought we would see a couple of years ago, and I think really because we've had very good fee schedules here in California, the impact of medical inflation was delayed a little bit. We are now starting to see significant growth in paid medical services per claim in 2024, attributed to a recent growth in the number of medical transactions per claim and a continued increase in paid per transaction.

So one of the other things that happened a couple of years ago is they redid the fee schedule for medical legal services and we've seen increases for medical legal services per claim also with an increase of 15% in 2024. So those numbers are now starting to hit and they're really pretty big numbers.

DG: Yeah, so when you talk about medical cost inflation, that's something I think our audience is probably well aware of just in their own health insurance costs. I mean, what we're talking about here is you go to the doctor for some procedure, it's going to be more expensive today than it was five years ago, simply because of inflation in the medical arena. Is that kind of what we're talking about?

MH: Absolutely.

DG: Yeah. So that eventually is going to trickle into the premium, the losses and all of those things for when we consider workers' compensation, it's going to pull into that arena as well. So that's it. That's a cost driver, an increase that has to be accounted for.

MH: Absolutely.

DG: Yeah.

MH: The fee schedules have now caught up with medical inflation.

DG: Yeah. What else is driving this Margaret?

MH: So we've also seen a slight increase in indemnity payments of about 3%, which is driving indemnity claim and just an indemnity claim is really a lost time claim, a claim that it's not just a need for medical but also disability payments.

DG: Right. So you're going to be away from work.

MH: Right. So the projected severity on indemnity claims for 2024 was 6% higher than in 2023. And the average severity in 2024 is the highest it's been in more than a decade. So we, so we talked a lot about the workers' compensation market and how great the Senate Bill 863 reforms that happened several years ago were on the industry. Well, now we're starting to see that some of those increases creep back in. And so we're seeing indemnity claim frequency also on top of the severity. So it's kind of a double whammy.

DG: Yeah, so more serious claims and more often.

MH: More often.

Yeah, okay.

MH: Now, interestingly, this is what we're going to talk a little bit about, start to talk about CT claims. There was a lot of volatility obviously in frequency during the pandemic years, but then we started to see claims frequency start to tick up and really the sharp increase in the frequency of claims really involves these cumulative trauma or continuous trauma claims that we're going to talk about here in a minute. That started really in 2022 and has continued through the beginning of this year as well. So if you take those claims out of the system, there's a slight actually decline in frequency. So those are really what's driving claims frequency here in California.

DG: Okay. So CT claims is the major driver for this cost increases. So you mentioned it, but before we jump into the topic, just for the audience, how do you define Cumulous Trauma, a CT claim? What is that?

MH: Okay. Yeah, I'm happy to describe what that is.

DG: Give it a shot.

MH: I'm also going to tell you, though, that one last thing on the increases, because these continuous trauma claims are typically litigated, there’s also been a big increase in loss adjustment expenses and we saw a 10 % jump in 2024. So a lot of that 11.2 % increase is driven by these negative trends, including this big impact on continuous trauma. So now I'm going to delve into what is this and you may hear the term cumulative trauma, continuous trauma, RMI, of motion injury, repetitive stress injuries.

The thing that's in comment about these claims is they occur gradually over time. So it's not a specific incident that causes it, but it's a gradual onset. And they result from repetitive stress or continuous exposure or chronic overuse of a body part during work activities. So to give you a couple of examples of repetitive stress injuries is carpal tunnel syndrome, which happens of the risks from repetitive typing. You can have back pain from chronic heavy lifting or bending and stooping.

Hearing loss is another form of continuous trauma from prolonged exposure to loud machinery. You have respiratory claims from prolonged exposure to chemicals.

So those are just some examples of what a continuous trauma claim is.

DG: And that doesn't seem, I mean, obviously some of this could be industry specific. I think about the construction industry, as you know, we focus quite heavily on that. We see a lot of these types of claims from what you were talking about, the lifting, just the year over year over year of doing that manual work. But it's not limited just to construction, right? You're seeing these CT claims across the board, whether it's an office exposure, a manufacturer, hospitality, construction, doesn't really matter, is that?

MH: Absolutely.

DG: Okay. What do you, in your view, what have these CT claims met to the overall performance of workers' compensation claims in California? How big of an impact have they really had?

MH: Well, in talking about the numbers that went into that recommended increase, I mean, CT claims have had a pretty significant impact on our overall system. They're also, interestingly, kind of California -specific. We write workers' compensation, of course, in all states. And we really see this phenomenon here in California. They are typically litigated. 70 % of the continuous trauma claims that we see are litigated, which results in longer claim duration. So they're open longer, they're going to stay on an employer's experience mod longer. So there's a lot of challenges in trying to get these claims resolved. It's typically not a quick resolution. Often there's other carriers involved since they happen a prolonged period of time. They limit it to a year, but there could be two or more different employers that are involved in these claims. So, they can be rather complicated. And then, you know, applicants, attorneys here in California have been very aggressive about using social media and a lot of advertising to kind of get the word out and sometimes even kind of convince workers that the aging process itself is part of their continuous trauma.

And then the other interesting thing that's happened with CT claims recently is they were really, really prevalent in Southern California. So it's kind of started in the LA Basin and expanded throughout Southern Cal. But, you know, there was often talk about there was it was a tale of two states. Southern California had all these issues with CT claims. We didn't see them in the North. Now we're starting to see them. Since 2022, big increases in Northern California and the Central Valley as well.

One of the theories behind why that's happening, which I think makes a lot of sense, is that with the pandemic, a lot of things pivoted, a lot of these legal proceedings now have pivoted to virtual, so they don't have to go to the board to prove the case. The attorneys now can have clients all over the state, it doesn't really matter, and then handle depots and hearings virtually, so it's made it a lot easier for them to get clients that are outside of their area. So we've seen these claims really balloon and expand.

DG: So, that's kind of like you said that's a residual of the COVID years right that's what it had to be enacted and that's just continued.

MH: Right.

DG: Yeah so you know I'm already thinking of some solutions here but let's power forward here a little bit further. So are there any ways potential reform changes in the laws that you can see that might help tune this around?

MH: Well, you know, absolutely, there's opportunities for reform. For one, just tightening the standards around how CT claims are filed and accepted could help. The threshold in California is vague and really leaves the door open for some questionable claims.

Today, really, an introvert only has to prove 1% of work causation cause their disability. So they could have all sorts of pre -existing conditions, but if the work environment contributed even just very slightly like the 1%, that CT claim would be accepted. So you may get some apportionment on permanent disability, but you still, the employer would be responsible for the medical treatment and the temporary disability for that claim. So tightening up some of those thresholds years and years ago in California, we were seeing the same thing. It was just a flurry of mental health psychological claims and with the same threshold and they actually changed the threshold. So now for a pure site claim where there's no other specific incident, post -traumatic stress type situation, that's involved, it's a continuous trauma type of cycling, the work has to be the predominant cause of that. So it's like it's more of a 51% threshold. So maybe doing something like that.

DG: So I mean, that makes total sense to me, of course. What would it take to get something like that done? Why isn't that happening right now?

MH: Yeah, I think the biggest problem is that, you know, it's California right now is having problems with property insurance with a wildfire situation that we have here, auto insurance, there's just not been a focus on workers comp. Workers comp rates have just continued to decline for the past several years, so there hasn't really been any big efforts to make any changes there.

Now that we're seeing rates start increasing, we may see some reform. The California Workers Comp Institute is saying maybe in 2026, I think it's probably going to take a little bit longer than that before, you know, we see any types of changes. I think one of the other things that could be addressed to is really how post termination claims are handled because, you know, we still continue to see these post termination layoff claims where, you know, the insured has a layoff and then we see multiple claims filed often with the same attorney, same types of pleadings.

DG: So, on those post termination claims, is there any timeframe, post termination that they have to file the claim? Is it a year for that as well?

MH: It's not. So, a post term specific injury, there is a statute of limitations of a year, but not for a post-term continuous trauma because if the employee doesn't know that they're injured, they can't report the claim. And since the CT happens over time, the threshold is when you knew or should have known that you had a disability and an injury and so you have to have proof that they went to a doctor and someone told them they were injured and that kind of thing.

DG: So that leaves that door pretty wide open.

MH: Exactly.

DG: And just for the audience, we will get to some solutions that you can do as an employer to maybe try to mitigate some of these things. So what we really are trying to do is let's just get the issues on the table, try to really understand them, and then let's go about trying to put some fixes in place that in your companies that you might be able to do to try to help this situation. We're not going to be able to let it, we're not going to get it to go away until there's more reform. And as Margaret said earlier, that's going to take some time. But I think it's all employer groups, unions, associations, things like that. Now is the time to start to put some focus on, putting some pressure on Sacramento to try to get these things higher on the list and not let it just sit behind the wildfires and the other issues we have in California.

MH: Sure. And I want to add too that we don't want to take legitimate benefits away from somebody who's injured, but we have seen a lot of abuse with these types of claims and that's what we need to get out of the system.

DG: Yeah. I just, I mean, we can talk about the frustration and, you now, the accounts that we manage and work with and, you know, you just see where body parts become separate claims, you know, so it's a CT claim, first it's a shoulder, then a week later it's an ankle, then it becomes a back, an arm, you know, so these are just multiple claims then, which have individual costs, which again really impact the EMR's experience, lots of things like that.

Margaret, listen, I can't thank you enough for joining me today in StudioOne and kind of sharing your insights to this changing worker compensation marketplace.

And thank you all for joining me today in Studio One. If you found this information useful, you can subscribe to our podcast channel, which is StudioOne, all one word, and it can be found on literally all the podcast applications. So thank you again for your time. Goodbye for now.

WCIRB 2024 Construction Dual Wage Threshold Increases Approved

California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara has approved an increase in hourly wage thresholds for all 16 construction dual-wage classifications.

The increases range from $1 to $4 depending on the classification and will go into effect for policyholders on their workers’ compensation policy renewal date on or after September 1, 2024. The chart below outlines the proposed increases for each classification.

Dual Wage Classifications	Existing Threshold	Proposed Increase	Proposed Threshold
5027/5028 Masonry	$32	$3	$35
5190/5140 Electrical Wiring	$34	$2	$36
5183/5187 Plumbing	$31	$1	$32
5185/5186 Automatic Sprinkler	$32	$1	$33
5201/5205 Concrete Work	$32	$1	$33
5403/5432 Carpentry	$39	$2	$41
5446/5447 Wallboard Installation	$38	$3	$41
5467/5470 Glaziers	$36	$3	$39
5474/5482 Painting Waterproofing	$31	$1	$32
5484/5485 Plastering or Stucco	$36	$2	$38
5538/5542 Sheet Metal Work	$29	$4	$33
5552/5553 Roofing	$29	$2	$31
5632/5633 Steel Framing	$39	$2	$41
6218/6220 Grading/Land Leveling	$38	$2	$40
6307/6308 Sewer Construction	$38	$2	$40
6315/6316 Water/Gas Mains	$38	$2	$40

In light of the ongoing labor shortage within the construction industry, employers have been making a concerted effort to retain their workforce. This includes providing more comprehensive benefits packages, including higher wages, and merit-based bonuses when appropriate. As a result, these new wage classification increases may prompt employers to consider extending further salary increases to their employees, with the aim of reducing workers' compensation premiums.

To better understand these changes and plan for the impact this will have on your company, please call us at 619-937-0164 and ask to speak to a member of our construction group.

WCIRB Files for Workers’ Comp Rate Increase

Author, Sam Clayton, Vice President, Construction Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Earlier this month, the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) recommended a nominal .9% increase in the advisory pure premium rates. The reason given, increased loss development for medical costs and higher claims adjustment expenses. This recommendation is now sent to the California’s Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara for approval. If approved, the increase in rates then take effect September 1, 2024.

Recognizing that a .9% increase is not very significant and in 2023 the WCIRB requested a similar increase which ultimately was denied by Commissioner Lara, the message remains clear that  workers’ compensation rates have probably bottomed out.

This does not mean every business will see an increase. There will still be reductions in some class codes pure premium rates and pricing will be more tied to Experience Modification Rate (EMR) decreases and an individual company’s claims experience. For distressed accounts, companies whose EMR is increasing and have had poor claim experience, will likely see an increase in their rates.

In order to stay ahead of this, we recommend companies review their key performance indicators (KPIs) that measure and compare a company’s frequency and severity of claims to their peers within the same governing class code. These metrics allow a company to identify trends, design programs that will address specific training needs, and project claims costs that will ultimately impact their EMR.

In addition, we recommend working closely with your claim advocate to assist in monitoring open workers’ compensation claims, and identify any open claims under your company’s primary threshold that could be closed prior to your unit stat filing that can impact your EMR.

If you would like to learn more about the pure premium rate’s impact by class code or evaluate your specific KPIs, I can be reached at (619) 937-0167 or via email at sclayton@ranchomesa.com.

Cracking the Code: Deciphering the Primary Threshold’s Impact

Author, Greg Garcia, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Every business owner understands the correlation between their Experience MOD (XMOD) and what they will pay in workers’ compensation premiums.  When the XMOD increases, there is a good chance that the workers’ compensation rates or premiums will rise as well.  This is why it is so crucial to really hone in on company safety procedures to limit work-related injuries as much as possible.  The reality is that even the safest company that does everything the right way is going to run into a workers’ compensation claim from time to time.

So, when the inevitable workers’ compensation claim happens, what are you supposed to do?  What impact will this have on the XMOD?  The first component that business owners need to understand is that there is a cap to how much any single workers’ compensation claim can impact the XMOD.  That cap is called the primary threshold.  The primary threshold varies from company to company and is based off of the company’s payroll.  The more payroll a company has the higher the primary threshold.

For this example, a company has a primary threshold of $15,000 where the maximum number of points that any one claim can impact the XMOD once reaching the threshold is 10 points.  This means that a claim that costs $15,000 and a claim that cost $150,000 will have the same impact (10 points against the XMOD).  However, this does not mean that claims that exceed the primary threshold can be disregarded, because the higher claim cost you have will impact your current and 5-year loss ratio (incurred claim cost/premium paid).  Additionally, if a claim that was reserved higher than the primary threshold and can be closed or decreased lower than the primary threshold, XMOD points can be shaved off of that claim.

Knowing the importance of the primary threshold, we designed our proprietary the KPI dashboard that allows our clients to see their primary threshold number and corresponding maximum impact to the XMOD any one primary threshold claim would have. 

If you have any questions about your XMOD or would like us to create a KPI for your company, please feel free to reach out to me at (619) 438-6905 or ggarcia@ranchomesa.com.

WCIRB Proposes 2024 Construction Dual Wage Threshold Increase

The Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) has proposed an increase in hourly wage thresholds for all 16 construction dual-wage classifications.

The increases range from $1 to $4 depending on the classification and if approved will go into effect for policyholders renewing September 1, 2024 and thereafter. The chart below outlines the proposed increases for each classification.

Dual Wage Classifications	Existing Threshold	Proposed Increase	Proposed Threshold
5027/5028 Masonry	$32	$3	$35
5190/5140 Electrical Wiring	$34	$2	$36
5183/5187 Plumbing	$31	$1	$32
5185/5186 Automatic Sprinkler	$32	$1	$33
5201/5205 Concrete Work	$32	$1	$33
5403/5432 Carpentry	$39	$2	$41
5446/5447 Wallboard Installation	$38	$3	$41
5467/5470 Glaziers	$36	$3	$39
5474/5482 Painting Waterproofing	$31	$1	$32
5484/5485 Plastering or Stucco	$36	$2	$38
5538/5542 Sheet Metal Work	$29	$4	$33
5552/5553 Roofing	$29	$2	$31
5632/5633 Steel Framing	$39	$2	$41
6218/6220 Grading/Land Leveling	$38	$2	$40
6307/6308 Sewer Construction	$38	$2	$40
6315/6316 Water/Gas Mains	$38	$2	$40

In light of the ongoing labor shortage within the construction industry, employers have been making a concerted effort to retain their workforce. This includes providing more comprehensive benefits packages, including higher wages, and offering merit-based bonuses when appropriate. As a result, these proposed wage classification increases may prompt employers to consider extending further salary increases to their employees, with the aim of reducing workers' compensation premiums.

Rancho Mesa predicts that this information will become a major factor in payroll decisions based on overhead cost management and recommend this as a topic for discussion early, so that our clients and prospects can prepare.

Implementing Technology and Other Safety Tactics to Protect Your Fleet

Author, Greg Garcia, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

One of the most important practices for any landscape professional is fleet safety. Whether you have 10 trucks or 100, the exposure and risk remain the same. Explore a prior podcast episode, Episode #251, in which I delve into compelling statistics that shed light on the increasing frequency and severity of auto accidents each year.

Here are a few ways landscape professionals can improve their fleet safety:

1. GPS/Telematics Systems

A written fleet safety program is a must have for every organization, but how can you take that a step further? Some landscape professionals are turning to technology and installing GPS tracking systems in all of their trucks. These systems have the capabilities of tracking speeding, hard breaking, sharp turning, proper seat belt usage and other metrics. Not to mention, if a truck were ever stolen, they have the capabilities to track down and locate the stolen vehicle. 

I was at the National Association of Landscape Professionals’ (NALP) ELEVATE conference a few weeks back in Dallas and spoke with a landscaper who uses GPS on their trucks. I asked how they use the data that is collected. Their response was that each month they sit down and look at the data. They identify any glaring issues and work to get them resolved. For example, if a certain driver has been tracked speeding multiple times, they will sit that driver down and explain the importance of not speeding. They may even have them do a specific driver training course to help that individual become a better driver. Having GPS is a great start to improving fleet safety, but actually using the data collected and being proactive with that data is what the elite landscape company do.

2. Regular routine maintenance checks on vehicles

GPS tracks a vehicle while it’s driven, but what can be done before the vehicle even hits the road to help prevent accidents?  Routinely checking vehicles and performing maintenance on them can really have a impact on fleet safety. For example, regularly checking tire pressure, making sure oil changes are up to date, inspecting the brakes and monitoring tire wear are a few things that every landscape company should do to keep their vehicles running in tip top condition. 

3. Company Roll Out Procedure

Implementing a mandatory company roll-out check can have a significant impact. I have actually seen a few of these performed in person and it’s impressive. As the trucks leave the yard to head out for the day’s work, the driver signals both blinkers, flashes the headlights, cleans the windshield and mirrors, and performs a small brake check, all the while, an inspector is outside making sure all signals are working before the truck heads out. 

Finally, if a trailer is being used, check to make sure the trailer is properly hitched and the equipment in the trailer is tied down or stored securely. Taking time and performing these checks will certainly help prevent auto accidents in the future.

If you would like more information on putting together or updating your Fleet Safety program, reach out to me at ggarcia@ranchomesa.com or (619) 438-6905.

Pure Premium Increase for Landscape (0042) in Consecutive Years

Author, Greg Garcia, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

In September 2022, the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) recommended a 9% increase in the pure premium rate for landscape class code 0042. Effective September of 2023, a 4% increase was recently approved, totaling 13% over the two-year span.

Pure Premium Rates arise from losses sustained and payroll submitted to the WCIRB from all workers’ compensation insurance companies. Per the California Department of Insurance (CDI), “Pure Premium Rates” are defined as “the cost of workers' compensation benefits and the expense to provide those benefits.” The WCIRB evaluates each individual class code and determines what the recommended rates will be for the upcoming year. This recommendation is made to the CDI who ultimately needs to reject or approve the recommendation. Once the pure premium rates are approved, each workers’ compensation insurance carrier will apply their individual least common multiple (LCM) which is an adjustment to the pure premium rate that takes into consideration business expenses and profit for the carrier, thus creating their individual base rates for each class code.

What does this all mean? The claim activity and claim cost as a whole have been increasing over the last two years for landscapes companies in California. This may signal the beginning of a hardening workers’ compensation market resulting in higher premium cost. 

What can be done to help combat these potential increases in premium? An increased attention to safety practices to reduce claims, a robust return to work program to mitigate cost of existing claims, proactive claim management, and consistent, documented safety training are a few of the ways that will help a landscape business remain best in class. 

Take control of your future costs and look to your existing risk management partners to help you accomplish your goals. For Rancho Mesa landscape clients, we do this through our customized and proprietary programs and tools, including:

• RM365 Advantage SafetyStar™ Certification Program

• Mobility & Stretch™ / A.B.L.E. Lift Protocol Program

• Key Performance Indicator (KPI) for workers’ compensation

• In-house workers’ compensation claims advocacy

• 52-week landscape-specific safety toolbox talk topics

• Monthly workshops and webinars

• New SafetyOne™ mobile app

These pure premium changes will take place on workers’ compensation insurance renewals after September of this year. Don’t be caught by surprise or unprepared.  We are here to help you proactively navigate through this. If you have any questions, want to learn more about our programs and tools, please feel free to reach out to me at ggarcia@ranchomesa.com or 619-438-6905.

California Insurance Commissioner Leaves Workers’ Comp Rates Flat

Author, Jeremy Hoolihan, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara released a statement that he is rejecting the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau’s (WCIRB) recommended 7.6% increase in the workers’ compensation pure premium rates as well as the add-on to cover COVID-19 claim costs. The Commissioner also rejected a more modest 2.8% increase recommended by the Department of Insurance’s actuaries and the 1.4% decrease recommended by an independent actuary for the public members of the Bureau’s governing committee. 

Commissioner Lara’s decision was based on California’s still recovering economy. With businesses trying to recover to pre-pandemic levels and the uncertainty still of COVID-19 disruptions, the Commissioner decided to keep the benchmark rate of $1.45 per $100 of payroll. Keep in mind that the pure premium rate is only advisory as the Commissioner does not have rate setting authority over workers’ compensation rates. In fact, the rate level of $1.45 is actually 18% lower than the industry filed average pure premium rate of $1.77 as of January 1, 2022.  

“We’re working hard to get California back to business as usual as people return to work,” said Lara. “This year’s rate is on par with normal, pre-pandemic levels while still reflecting the long-term benefits of workers’ compensation reform passed by the State Legislature and signed by the Governor to reduce costs.”

With signs of a hardening market such as increased carrier combined ratios, increased cost on indemnity claims, medical inflation, and future costs of COVID-19 claims, it will be interesting to see how carriers will respond to this decision. Now, more than ever, it is critical to work with your broker and carrier to improve your risk management program so that your business is positioned well for the future.  

If you are interested in how this process works and how it can improve your bottom line, please reach out to me at (619) 937-0174 or jhoolihan@ranchomesa.com. In the meantime, Rancho Mesa will keep close tabs on what the future holds and communicate updates regularly.

WCIRB Approves 2022 Construction Dual Wage Threshold Increase

The Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) has approved the recommended increase in hourly wage thresholds for all 16 construction dual wage classifications.

The increases range from $2 to $5 depending on the classification and will go into effect for policyholders renewing September 1, 2022 and thereafter. The chart below outlines the increases for each classification.

Dual Wage Classifications	Existing Threshold	Approved Increase	Approved Threshold
5027/5028 Masonry	$28	$4	$32
5190/5140 Electrical Wiring	$32	$2	$34
5183/5187 Plumbing	$28	$3	$31
5185/5186 Automatic Sprinkler	$29	$3	$32
5201/5205 Concrete Work	$28	$4	$32
5403/5432 Carpentry	$35	$4	$39
5446/5447 Wallboard Installation	$36	$2	$38
5467/5470 Glaziers	$33	$3	$36
5474/5482 Painting Waterproofing	$28	$3	$31
5484/5485 Plastering or Stucco	$32	$4	$36
5538/5542 Sheet Metal Work	$27	$2	$29
5552/5553 Roofing	$27	$2	$29
5632/5633 Steel Framing	$35	$4	$39
6218/6220 Grading/Land Leveling	$34	$5	$39
6307/6308 Sewer Construction	$34	$5	$39
6315/6316 Water/Gas Mains	$34	$5	$39

With the continuing labor shortage in construction, employers have been doing everything possible to retain employees by offering richer benefits plans, pay increases and merit bonuses, when applicable. These approved wage classification increases could potentially push employers to extend additional pay raises to employees in an effort to minimize workers’ compensation premiums.

Rancho Mesa predicts that this information will become a major factor in payroll decisions based on overhead cost management and recommend this as a topic for discussion early, so that our clients and prospects can prepare.

Understanding the Impact of MEP Contractors’ Dual Wage & Total Temporary Disability

Author, Sam Clayton, Vice President, Construction Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

What is a dual wage threshold? According to the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB), in California there are sixteen (16) construction operations that are divided into two separate classifications based on the hourly wage of the employee. There are different advisory pure premium rates for the low wage employee and the high wage employee. For mechanical, electrical and plumbing (MEP) contractors, the class codes used are all included in the recently approved increase which will go into effect September 1, 2022. The table below outlines the changes for the MEP class codes by year.

Classifications	9/1/2021 - Current	9/1/2022 - Proposed
5140/5190	$32	$34
5183/5187	$28	$31
5538/5542	$27	$29

© 2021 Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau of California. All Rights Reserved.

Why does this matter to MEP contractors? The higher wage employee’s workers’ compensation rate is significantly less (on average 46% less) than the lower wage employee. Therefore, if a company has any employees that are currently just barley in the high wage classification, this would drop those employees into the low wage classification and the employer would pay the higher workers’ compensation rate on those individuals. Depending on how many employees an employer has in this situation, it may be advantageous for the employer to calculate if it makes more sense to give those impacted employees a raise to push them back up into the high wage classification or keep them in the new low wage classification. It should be noted and understood that this change will not impact the employer until their next renewal after September 1, 2022. So while most employers will have time to evaluate the impact, it is crucial to begin the evaluation sooner rather than later.

As with any form of wage inflation, an increase in wages, to keep an employee in the higher wage category will increase the claim costs of a total temporary disability claim if they are injured on the job. While increases in wages are necessary, they will also impact the total cost of the claim, which then can increase the company’s experience modification rating (XMOD).

To mitigate this increase and reduce the likelihood of a lost time claim, employers can take several actions:

• Review and update their existing safety programs.

• Revisit their hiring practices.

• Develop a sustainable return-to-work program.

What should employers do next?

• Work with your trusted insurance advisor and run a needs/benefit analysis on increasing employee wages.

• Understand your numbers.

  • What is your primary threshold and why does it matter?

  • What is my claim cost per point of XMOD?

  • How does my frequency of claims compare to the MEP industry?

  • How does my lost time claim average compare to other MEP contractors?

If you would like assistance understanding how these and other data points impact your company, request a proprietary Key Performance Indicator (KPI) dashboard that puts this information at your fingertips.

You still have time to be proactive, do not let these critical changes catch you by surprise!

CA Insurance Bureau Recommends 7.6% Rate Increase

Author, Jack Marrs, Associate Account Executive, Human Services Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

The Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau of California (WCIRB) voted to submit a September 1, 2022 Pure Premium Rate Filing to California’s Insurance Commissioner Lara.

The filing will suggest a 7.6% average rate increase above last year’s approved September 1, 2021 pure premium rates.

There are multiple reasons for the WCIRB’s Governing Committee to suggest the rate increase. Most notably,

• There is an 11% projected increase to indemnity claim cost by the end of 2024.

• The industry predicts a 6.5% increase in medical costs per claim from 12/31/21 to 12/31/24.

• We expect increases in frequency of injuries and claims.

• Wage inflation will increase claim cost and the cost to adjust claims.

• Expected future costs of COVID-19 claims are likely to increase, which were previously excluded when underwriting considers claims history.

Before the increase goes into effect, the WCIRB will submit a proposal to the Department of Insurance. Insurance Commissioner Lara will decide to either approve the rate increase, or reject it and suggest a different outcome.

Although the commissioner cannot mandate any sort of rate increase or decrease, it is common for workers’ compensation carriers to cooperate with his recommendation and follow his lead.

This news is another sign that the California workers’ compensation insurance market may be hardening. With that in mind, it is crucial that employers are implementing trainings and safety programs to ensure workplace safety.

In addition, a strong broker partner must truly understand the clients’ industry, operations, and service needs.

Please contact Rancho Mesa to understand how to better prepare for an increase in claims costs and the hardening workers’ compensation marketplace.

WCIRB Proposes Expected Loss Rate Decrease for Landscape Industry

Author, Drew Garcia, Vice President, Landscape Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

The Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) has proposed a 2% decrease (from $2.42 to $2.37) in the expected loss rate for the landscape class code 0042. 

The proposed $2.37 would impact Experience Modifications (ExMod) for all workers’ compensation policies that take effect on or after September 1, 2022.

The expected loss rate is used to calculate each company’s individual ExMod within the industry. A decrease in the rate would generate lower expected losses and lower primary thresholds.  So, the lower number puts pressure on the ExMod to increase. Whereas, an increase in the expected loss rate would help provide some potential ExMod relief.

The proposed decrease would impact the lowest possible ExMod for landscape companies by increasing it about 5% or 2 to 3 ExMod points.

So, landscapers need to implement effective safety programs to ensure losses don’t exceed the new lower expected loss rate for the industry.  

To help landscape businesses manage their individual ExMod, Rancho Mesa introduced the KPI Dashboard in January 2021 to provide insights that help organization leaders stay informed and prepare for future changes like these.

If you’re not a Rancho Mesa client, and are a landscape business in California, we would welcome the opportunity to forecast your ExMod to help you better prepare. Contact me to request your customized KPI Dashboard.

2022 Construction Dual Wage Thresholds - An Early Look

Author, Kevin Howard, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

There are 16 construction workers’ compensation class code pairs in California, each set up as dual wage classifications. The purpose of these “split” class codes allows the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) and California insurers to better predict future risk and underwrite with more accuracy.

To illustrate the dual wage threshold, consider a seasoned laborer with years of safety training, exposure awareness, and familiarity with jobsite protocol. This employee is going to be less of a safety risk compared to an apprentice who is still learning his or her trade, the safety techniques and all of the skill associated with a trade. As one might imagine, statistics consistently show a much higher probability of an injury occurring with an apprentice versus a seasoned veteran or journeymen. So, having a dual wage threshold allows carriers to generate pricing based on the employees’ experience and likelihood of having an injury.

Exploring how this can directly impact rates and pricing, the 2021 roofing dual wage class codes of 5552 and 5553 is a great example.

Class code 5552 is defined as roofers who make less than $27 per hour. The average California worker’s compensation insurance base rate for this class code is $40 per $100 of payroll. Class code 5553 includes roofers who make $27 or more per hour. This class code’s average California workers’ compensation insurance base rate is $20 per $100 of payroll. In this example, the workers’ compensation premium base rate is half the cost for a more experienced employee over someone with less experience.

It is crucial for any roofing contractor to be mindful of this wage threshold data knowing that the delta in the 2022 recommended increase represents a staggering 61% gap between the two base rates.

Additionally, the WCIRB has continued to increase wage thresholds. This is to keep up with inflation of the US dollar, the increase in minimum wage and the demand for labor, among other factors.

Dual Wage Classification Thresholds by Year

Shown below are the wage thresholds for all dual wage classifications. For information about these classifications, see the California Workers' Compensation Uniform Statistical Reporting Plan—1995, effective September 1, 2021.

Classifications
Year	5027	5140	5183	5185	5201	5403	5446	5467	5474	5484	5538	5552	5632	6218	6307	6315
	5028	5190	5187	5186	5205	5432	5547	5470	5482	5485	5542	5553	5633	6620	6308	6316
9/1/2022	$32	$34	$31	$32	$32	$39	$38	$36	$31	$36	$29	$29	$39	$39	$39	$39
9/1/2021	$28	$32	$28	$29	$28	$35	$36	$33	$28	$32	$27	$27	$35	$34	$34	$34
1/1/2021	$28	$32	$28	$29	$28	$35	$36	$33	$28	$32	$27	$27	$35	$34	$34	$34
1/1/2020	$28	$32	$28	$29	$28	$35	$36	$33	$28	$32	$27	$27	$35	$34	$34	$34
1/1/2019	$27	$32	$26	$27	$25	$32	$34	$32	$26	$29	$27	$25	$32	$31	$31	$31
1/1/2018	$27	$32	$26	$27	$25	$32	$34	$31	$26	$29	$27	$25	$32	$31	$31	$31
1/1/2017	$27	$30	$26	$27	$24	$30	$33	$31	$24	$27	$27	$23	$30	$30	$30	$30

© 2021 Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau of California. All Rights Reserved.

WCIRB’s 2022 RECOMMENDATION:

The Bureau is considering raising the hourly wage threshold for all 16 dual wage classification pairs with some codes seeing as much as a $5.00 increase. The average delta between the lower advisory rate and higher advisory rate is 48%.

 Proposed Dual Wage Threshold Increases

Dual Wage Classifications	Existing Threshold	Proposed Increase	Proposed Threshold	Low Wage Advisory Rate	High Wage Advisory Rate	% Difference From Low Wage Rate
5027/5028 Masonry	$28	$4	$32	$8.18	$4.21	-48.50%
5190/5140 Electrical Wiring	$32	$2	$34	$3.76	$1.45	-61.40%
5183/5187 Plumbing	$28	$3	$31	$5.31	$2.36	-55.60%
5185/5186 Automatic Sprinkler	$29	$3	$32	$4.57	$1.00	-57.30%
5201/5205 Concrete Work	$28	$4	$32	$6.64	$1.95	-36.30%
5403/5432 Carpentry	$35	$4	$39	$10.03	$4.23	-55.10%
5446/5447 Wallboard Installation	$36	$2	$38	$5.42	$4.50	-55.10%
5467/5470 Glaziers	$33	$3	$36	$7.62	$2.65	-59.30%
5474/5482 Painting Waterproofing	$28	$3	$31	$8.09	$3.10	-46.40%
5484/5485 Plastering or Stucco	$32	$4	$36	$9.98	$4.34	-37.40%
5538/5542 Sheet Metal Work	$27	$2	$29	$5.07	$2.52	-50.30%
5552/5553 Roofing	$27	$2	$29	$21.05	$8.14	-61.30%
5632/5633 Steel Framing	$35	$4	$39	$10.03	$4.50	-55.10%
6218/6220 Grading/Land Leveling	$34	$5	$39	$5.10	$2.93	-42.50%
6307/6308 Sewer Construction	$34	$5	$39	$6.98	$2.84	-59.30%
6315/6316 Water/Gas Mains	$34	$5	$39	$4.18	$3.70	-11.50%

This recommendation, if approved by the insurance commissioner, would become effective September 1, 2022.

With the continuing labor shortage in the construction arena, employers have been doing everything possible to retain employees by offering richer benefits plans, pay increases and merit bonuses, when applicable. These recommended wage classification increases could potentially push employers to extend additional pay raises to employees in an effort to minimize workers’ compensation premiums.

It is best for contractors who utilize any of the 16 dual wage classification pairs to be aware of the potential increases and to do the math to see if it makes sense to consider raises prior to your 2022-2023 September 1st workers’ compensation renewal.

Rancho Mesa predicts that this info will become a major factor in payroll decisions based on overhead cost management and recommend this as a topic for discussion early so that our clients, prospects and listeners can prepare.

To discuss how the proposed dual wage threshold increases may affect your business, contact me at (619) 438-6874 or khoward@ranchomesa.com.

How Rising Pure Premium Rates Will Impact the Tree Care Industry

Author, Rory Anderson, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

In California, each workers’ compensation insurance company has its own set of base rates for each class of business. In order to come up with their base rate for each class code, the insurance carrier applies their Loss Cost Multiplier (LCM) to the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau’s (WCIRB) pure premium rates.

Pure premium rates are determined by the WCIRB and include the loss cost of claims for that particular class of business. Those costs include:

• The cost of the claim itself (i.e., indemnity, medical and expense payments)

• Loss adjustment expenses  

• Future loss adjustment expenses (e.g., fees for expert witnesses and salary/overhead for outside legal counsel)

A pure premium rate reflects the amount of losses that an insurance carrier can expect to pay out in claims for that class of business. Every 6 months, the WCIRB submits pure premium rates to the California Department of Insurance for approval. These pure premium rates are based on loss and payroll data submitted to the WCIRB by all the insurance companies in California.

A carrier’s LCM will include those additional expenses separate of the pure premium rate considerations. These would include a carrier’s:

• General overhead expenses (e.g., rent, payroll, employee benefits, etc.)

• Sales and Marketing

• Taxes, licenses and fees

• Profit

The 2021 pure premium rate in the tree care industry (class code 0106) has increased to $10.50 per $100 in payroll, which is roughly a 3.5% increase from last year’s $10.15. This means that the overall workers’ compensation claim activity in the tree care industry is up about 3.5%, and the WCIRB is recommending that workers’ compensation insurance carriers increase their base rates to address this change.

As a tree care professional, what can your company do to prepare for this change and mitigate the impact to your business? Reviewing your claims experience, benchmarking your company with the tree care industry, looking for root causes of the claims, and then implementing best practices safety trainings will go a long way in providing you a path to insulate you from future changes like these.

As part of our proprietary TreeOne™ program, we have created a Key Performance Indicator (KPI) dashboard for the tree care industry that puts this information at your fingertips. To see how you compare with your peers, request the KPI Dashboard for your company.

For more information on rising pure premium rates, contact me at (619) 486-6437 or randerson@ranchomesa.com.

Bond Companies Thoroughly Track Status of Construction Projects

Author, Matt Gaynor, Director of Surety, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

When the bond company approves a performance and payment bond for our contractor clients, they want to keep track of the project until completion - at which time the liability for the bond is no longer on their books. One tool they use to track a construction project is the Work In Progress Report (WIP) which the bonding company analyzes on a quarterly or six-month basis to track the profitability of the project on a percentage of completion basis. When the bond company sees that a project is 100% complete on the WIP or Completed Contract Report, they will mark the bond file as “closed,” once the warranty period has expired.

Additionally, several bond companies will also use a Contract Bond Status Inquiry Form to track the projects. This form is mailed to the obligee (i.e., the owner or general contractor on the bonded project) and requests project information is completed on the form, then returned to the bond company via mail, email, or fax. The questions posed on the form include, “Is the contract completed, and if so, what was the completion date and final contract amount?” In the event the contract is on-going, the form requests a percentage of completion or approximate dollar amount of the work completed to date. The form also asks the owner if they are aware of any unpaid bills for labor or material on the project.

The final area of the status inquiry form provides space for the obligee to fill in remarks. This can be a good or bad thing for the contractor. We have seen responses from owners and general contractors that range from “great subcontractor – excellent to work with” to “I will never hire this contractor again.” Other times, this area is left blank. 

While the primary goal of the status inquiry is to understand if a project is closed or remains open, the remarks section will grab the bond underwriters attention (positive or negative) and that will become part of their underwriting analysis, going forward.

If you would like more information on how the contract bond status inquiry might influence the underwriting of your bond program, feel free to reach out to me at (619) 937-0165 or mgaynor@ranchomesa.com and ask any questions to ensure your bond program is getting the proper attention.

Strengthen Your Risk Profile During COVID-19

Author, Jeremy Hoolihan, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

COVID-19 continues to have a stronghold on the US economy and it is likely that we will see the impact for many years to come. While the effects of COVID-19 on the workers’ compensation marketplace vary among the different business sectors, the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) has approved a filing that will increase the 2021 pure premium advisory rates by 2.6%. Understand that this recommended rate increase comes against a backdrop of record profits in workers’ compensation prior to COVID-19. There are also three COVID-19 presumption Bills (AB 196, AB 644, and SB 1159) that could create presumptions that cases of COVID-19 are a compensable consequence of work, which will likely cause additional turmoil in the marketplace.

With impending rate increases on the horizon, it’s more important now than ever to be proactive when it comes to your company’s risk management program. Carriers are already tightening up their underwriting guidelines and limiting schedule credits. In order to earn the most competitive pricing possible, a business must differentiate itself from other businesses. Below are three strategies you can use to strengthen your risk profile during COVID-19.     

Improve the Safety Program

Now is not the time to take your focus off of safety in the workplace. In fact, I would argue that there should be even more focus on safety. Some items to focus on relating to a safety program include:

1. Update your Injury and Illness Protection Program (IIPP) and have it reviewed by a labor attorney.

2. Establish a safety committee consisting of ownership, supervisors, managers, your insurance broker, and insurance company (i.e., loss control representative). This will assist with identifying workplace hazards, discussing claims or near misses that have occurred and creating safety meeting topics that can be discussed at future employee safety meetings.

3. Ensure that safety meetings are occurring at least every 10 working days, but preferably weekly. Using safety topics identified by the safety committee, managers can pinpoint proper trainings for employees.

Update Employee Handbook

With employment requirements, policies and procedures continually changing, it’s easy to fall behind on new regulations like adding an Emergency Paid Sick Leave Policy or Expanded Family and Medical Leave Policy, in your employee handbook. Rancho Mesa offers access to a living handbook builder through the RM365 HRAdvantage™ portal. By creating a living employee handbook through the portal, updating the document with new policies is as easy as reviewing and approving the suggested changes provided by experienced human resources professionals. 

Continue Your Risk Management Education and Certifications

With many businesses slowing during COVID-19, consider filling that down time with required accreditations and continued education courses.  Some examples include:

1. Anti-harassment Training: By the end of 2020, businesses with 5 or more employees are required to provide Anti-harassment training to all employees. Owners, supervisors, and management are required to complete the two-hour course, while all other employees must complete a one-hour course. Rancho Mesa offers free online Anti-harassment training for both supervisors/managers and employees. The courses can be accessed by computer, tablet, and a smart phone. 

2. Continued education or achieving professional designations: It’s also a good time to consider working on continued education courses such as renewing forklift certifications, OSHA trainings, as well as any professional designations. To reinvest your efforts in continued education, now, while business is still slow due to COVID-19, could position your business to hit the ground running when the economy opens up again.

3. Safety Star Certification – With underwriting guidelines tightening and worker’s compensation premiums expected to increase due to COVID-19, Rancho Mesa’s RM365 Advantage Safety Star Program™ can build your risk profile and differentiate your business from others. The program is designed for supervisors, foreman, safety coordinators, upper management, administrators, and directors of human resources. To earn the Safety Star certification in Construction Safety, you must complete the required Incident Investigation and Analysis online module plus at least two other modules of your choice from the approved list. This certification is also a marketing tool your broker can use to show your commitment to safety.

Proactively improving your safety program, employee handbook, and continuing education during the pandemic will allow you to hit the ground running once COVID-19 restrictions are lifted. It can also position your business to mitigate increasing premiums with the ever tightening workers’ compensation marketplace. 

If you need any assistance in implementing a sound risk management program, please reach out to me at (619) 937-0174.

Choosing the Right Classcode: A Guide to Distinguishing Tree Trimming from Landscape Work

Author, Rory Anderson, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Many tree care companies perform work that could be classified as “landscape gardening.” The risk and exposure associated with this class code is minimal compared to those associated with tree trimming. Without the additional tree care exposure, landscape gardening workers’ compensation insurance rates are significantly lower than tree trimming rates. Common questions we receive from our tree care clients are:

• What is the difference between the two class codes?

• I’ve always only used 0106-Tree Trimming, is it possible for me to use 0042-Landscape Gardening as well?

• How can I differentiate which specific operations are considered landscape gardening and which are considered tree trimming?

When more than one classification applies to operations that are closely related, it is important to understand the boundaries of each classification. Let’s take a look at how the California Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Board (WCIRB) defines both class codes:

0106 Tree Pruning, Repairing or Trimming

This classification applies to pruning, repairing or trimming trees or hedges when any portion of the operations requires elevation, including but not limited to using ladders, lifts or by climbing. This classification includes clean-up, chipping or removal of debris; stump grinding or removal; and tree spraying or fumigating that are performed in connection with tree pruning, repairing or trimming. This classification also applies to the removal of trees that retain no timber value.

0042 Landscape Gardening

This classification applies to the construction, maintenance, repair or installation of landscape systems or facilities designed for public or private gardens or other areas in order to aesthetically, architecturally, horticulturally or functionally improve the grounds within or surrounding a structure or a tract or plot of land. This classification includes the preparation and grading of plots or areas of land for the installation of landscaping; pruning, repairing or trimming trees or hedges when none of the operations at a particular job or location require elevation, including but not limited to using ladders, lifts or by climbing; or chipping operations performed in connection with landscape gardening. This classification also applies to spraying or spreading lawn fertilizers or herbicides, or weed abatement for fire hazard control purposes.

According to these definitions, a tree company may be able to use the 0042 landscape class code at specific times. However, when any of the operations are off the ground, that payroll would be classified in tree trimming 0106. Also, any type of work that is associated with the tree trimming (e.g., clean-up, chipping, stump grinding, etc.) will also be included as 0106. Here is a quick real-world example that will help to clarify.

A tree company has 10 employees that worked on a specific job to trim a large Eucalyptus tree. There were only two workers that actually climbed and trimmed the tree, and all the rest of the employees worked on the ground to clean up the limbs and branches that were being cut and fell from the tree. All 10 employees must be classified into the 0106 class code because the ground crew operations were in connection with the tree trimming, where the climbers were operating off of the ground.

The next day, on a completely different job site, the same tree company with 10 employees worked on a new job to trim a handful of 8 ft Japanese maple trees. For this job, all of the work was performed from the ground and there was never a point where any of the workers operated from elevation (e.g., ladders, lifts, climbing, etc.). Three of the workers trimmed with pole saws from the ground, while the other seven employees cleaned-up the debris and used the chipper. All 10 of the employees could be classified into the 0042 landscape class code because there was never a time where a worker left the ground to trim.

Properly documenting and maintaining valid records is critical in order for your company to utilize both class codes properly. Without proper documentation, you could be setting your company up for a large additional premium owed at audit.

Stay tuned to my follow up article and podcast as I share how to prepare for and execute a successful audit when both of these two class codes are applicable to your operations.