Author, Anne Wright, Surety Relationship Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.
When the surety provides the performance and/or payment bond required by a contract, that contract is the basis of the surety’s guarantee. Simply put, the bonds follow the contract. Because of this, there are a few key things that the surety is going to want to review, and you should do the same. The goal is to make sure you, as the contractor, have everything in place to ensure your success.
1. Liquidated Damages
Typically, contracts will have a liquidated damages provision. This is generally the per day penalty imposed in the event you are the cause of a delay for the completion of the project. If you are acting as a subcontractor and can only find vague verbiage in your contract with the general contractor (GC), it probably implies that you are held to the same liquidated damages as the GC is to the owner. Make sure you know the actual value or dollar amount of the liquidated damages and consider your bid amount accordingly. Just because you don’t see a dollar amount per day in the contract doesn’t mean you won’t be held to that flow down provision from the prime contract.
Private jobs may be more flexible. Most all public jobs will have something in the prime contract about liquidated damages and they can get pretty steep. We’ve recently seen invitations for bids that include $40,000/day liquidated damages. How many days delay would it take to eat up your profit on a given job? If you do run up against these higher liquidated damages, consider either conditioning your bid to include verbiage that either caps those liquidated damages to some dollar amount that is reasonable, or include a provision that you will only be responsible for a proportionate share of the liquidated damages based specifically on your work that may have caused any delay.
2. Retention
The standard retention for public works contracts in California is 5% for the prime contractor as a result of the efforts of our subcontractors association. Notably, this standard practice is scheduled to sunset in 2023. There is a bill in Sacramento to make the standard permanent. You can bet groups are lobbying to support the 5% standard as it has proven to be a good number.
Knowing the standard retention is important when negotiating your contract. If you are a subcontractor to a GC on a public works project, review the contract for the retention provision. You may be agreeing to abide by a percentage that is higher than what the GC is having withheld by the prime contract. For example, you may be asked to agree to a 10% retention instead of the standard 5%. That is a business decision you can make, but at least you know the law and consider it in your negotiations.
On private works projects, the owners can set their retention amount. And, we continue to see that being set at 10% for the prime contracts.
3. Indemnity
California law sets a limit to some extent on what one party can be liable for to another party. That said, some contracts may be out of date (i.e., broad form indemnity was the law of the land years ago), or the contract may have been drafted in another state. So, make sure that your indemnity provision clarifies that in no event will your duty to indemnify the other party be greater than what is defined as your scope in your contract and that you are not responsible for work performed by other trades.
4. Insurance Provisions
Insurance requirements are greater in some contracts than others. Limits of liability needed can change from contract to contract. It is best practices is to have your insurance agent review the contract before you sign. Make sure you have the coverages you need and include the cost in your contract amount. We’ve seen umbrella limits increasing with some public and private owners, so account for those increases.
5. Warranty
The standard warranty for workmanship in California is one year after completion. We do see some public owners wanting to extend that to a two-year warranty. In some trades and in some contracts, it might be longer. When presented with a longer term warranty, ask yourself if it is reasonable to expect you will be in a position to respond to a warranty item in X number of years after completion. We strongly suggest that you limit the warranty to no more than two years. In some cases, where bonds are required, the surety may ask for verbiage to be added to the contract to limit the surety’s liability to one or two years, and we will then include that in the bond form, if the provision exceeds the two years.
I have always held the belief that knowing a good construction-oriented attorney is as important as any other professional service provider you have to support your business. Consider that it is probably cheaper to have an attorney review your contract before you sign it, then to be put in a position to have to defend yourself later. A good legal resource can provide valuable input if you come across something new, or not well understood. We have some good resources that we can recommend. Contact me at (619) 486-6570 or awright@ranchomesa.com if you would like to discuss your surety needs or if we can provide other resources to support your business.